Give the game a rating from 1-5 in each category as described below.
The unexpected. Things in a unique combination, or something so different it’s notable.
How much you enjoyed playing a game. Did you look up at the clock and find it was 5 hours later than when you started?
How well an entry suits the theme. Do they perhaps do something creative or unexpected with the theme?
How good the game looks, or how effective the visual style is. Nice artwork, excellent generated or geometric graphics, charming programmer art, etc.
How good the game sounds, or how effective the sound design is. A catchy soundtrack, suitable sound effects given the look, voice overs, etc.
Storytelling, emotion, and the vibe you get while playing.
Your overall opinion of the game, in every aspect important to you.
Be sure you've selected what you want before clicking submit; once your vote is recorded there's no going back.